Thursday, Cannon Beach, Oregon
I have for some weeks been considering how to manage the dominance
social media has come to have over my daily life. I began to seriously consider
taking a break by simply deactivating during Lent as a Lenten penance as
several of my friends and acquaintances have done in past years. I had not seriously
considered going cold turkey in that fashion for the simple reason Facebook and
Instagram have weaseled their way into being a routine and common form of
communication. Rather than calling, sending a text message or even sending an
email, increasing numbers of people have taken to using messaging or posting on
my timeline as a way of communicating and I find it all too convenient to do
the same.
My thinking was that if I went cold turkey, I would miss out on not
learning something from someone important to me. I thought it might be easy to
just sign on to Facebook and then limit my attention to the red indicators telling
me I had been sent a friend request, a personal message or had simply tagged me
for some reason. The idea is that once the red lights were resolved, I would
simply close out the application before sneaking a peak at my Newsfeed.
That plan might work, it just might work. For a while
anyway. I am beginning to suspect, however, that for me the Newsfeed is like alcohol.
Once I scroll down one screen, I can’t stop until I have consumed everything
posted since the last time I checked in. I just can’t help myself.
In the aftermath of the 2012 and 2014 elections, the
political hubbub died down to the point I could enjoy posts offering news about
nieces, nephews and the rest of my family. I loved seeing pictures of soccer
matches, dance recitals, first communions, weddings, engagement parties. I was
sad to hear about pets that died or family and friends who were in grave peril
or who had passed away but I appreciated the ability to share those losses
those who hurting the same way I myself had been hurt in the past. I think it
is wonderful to be a regular participant in the lives of friends and family who
were once a big part of my daily life but who have now been separated by time
and space. I would not trade those re-connections for the world but I have to
also recognize the terrible cost I am paying at the same time.
When I look at Facebook now, I feel as though I have been
trapped a New York City traffic jam of epic proportions. Long streams of cars
have been jammed at an intersection and there is nowhere for any of the cars to
go to start the process of untangling the snarl. Many of us are leaning out the
windows yelling and cursing at everyone around them.
I understand the emotion. We all have something important to
say and no one is listening. I have important things to say but I don’t because
of the risk of being called a hater, a racist, a fascist, a misogynist – or
even worse. I would hope that anyone who has ever known me for more than two
minutes knows that while I have a very strong and well defined belief system I
would never want to be in a situation where anyone who disagrees me would feel
disparaged, minimized, or, worse yet, unloved. Pastor Tyler Amundson in a
recent column in the newspaper lamented the fact we seem to have forgotten how
to disagree. We have. I am seeing growing chasms between friends and family
members, including within my own family, because of the mounting bitterness and
anger rising out of a failed effort at dialogue that has faded into a
vituperative exercise in social warfare.
As for my plan to venture in the world of Facebook, I fear I
won’t be able to take care of business and move on but will instead find myself
being sucked back into the spectacle. I know for certain I will not be able to
wait until Lent to separate myself from discourse that seems to be growing
every day. I had hoped we call get back inside our cars and cooperate with each
other so we can move on down the road rather than uselessly laying on the horn.
I hoped we could start looking for the things we share and which bind us
together to remind us of what are looking for rather than hammering every larger
wedges into the divisions that separate and antagonize us. Instead, it is time
to make a change for sake of my sense of peace.
The events of the past year have reminded me I cannot change
anyone or anything. All I can do is to change how I respond to the people and
things that upset me. It is safe to say I have not said one thing on Facebook that
has changed the mind of a single person nor has anyone said anything that
changed my mind. Social media is not a place where effective change happen.
That kind of change only comes from a softening of the mind and a willingness
to listen respectfully to other.
I know peaceful discourse can be accomplished. I meet with a
group of men for a prayer group on Thursday mornings and we share a sense of
community and brotherhood that unites us because of a common love of the Gospel
and the firm conviction we can lead each other to a closer union with Christ.
We nurture our brotherhood and feed other with the fruit of our shared faith.
We are stronger and better for it, better men, better husbands, better fathers,
and better friends.
Understand, however, we are widely separated by our
politics. Some of us are progressives, others more middle of the road and the
rest of us would be considered rock-ribbed conservatives. Our differences do
not divide us because we abide by the challenges given by St. Francis to first
seek to understand rather than be understood. Peace fills each of us and
sustains us until we meet in prayer again the next week.
I know calling those I disagree with libtards, or snowflakes
is not going to lead anything fruitful. Likewise, calling me names is not going
to help your cause one bit. Compassion, empathy, curiosity and patience will
offer a better chance of meaningful change. I will also believe that as long as
each side justifies their inflammatory and judgmental verbal and written
expressions of outrage on the behavior of the other side, we will never find
peace. Someone has to step away from the smoking cannons and trust others will
do the same. I have despaired of this happening soon and I need to focus on
building up kingdom of God by making a positive contribution in other ways
other than devoting the amount of time I have been to social media. Maybe there
will be a way to continue to participate in the lives of the people important
to me, and you are ALL important to me, without risking my ability to find
peace in daily life.
For now, goodbye. Please, please, PLEASE do not think I am
blaming anyone for expressing themselves about issues they hold dear. I am,
instead, blaming myself because I know I have crossed the line from time to
time. It is my own actions and behavior that are prompting me to step back more
than anything I have encountered from others. Call me, text me, email me but don’t expect I
will respond if you reach out through Facebook. I might not hear you there. God
bless you and may He keep you in His care until we meet again. Peace.